Hello,
While fitting passive cable models to Cell Types Database cells (human and mouse, ~580 reconstructed cells with Short Square responses), I noticed what looks like a systematic change over time in how dendritic diameters were traced. I’d be grateful if someone from the morphology team could confirm whether this reflects a known change in the reconstruction pipeline.
What I see in the SWC files
- Two diameter conventions coexist. In some reconstructions no dendritic node has a diameter below 0.454 µm , with a large fraction of dendritic length sitting exactly at that value. In others, dendritic diameters go down to ~0.23 µm.
- The convention tracks specimen ID, i.e. acquisition order. In mouse cells the floored convention accounts for 0% of reconstructions with specimen IDs below 5.0 × 10⁸, ~8% between 5.0 and 5.5 × 10⁸, and ~81% above.
- Dendrites are traced thicker overall in later cells, not only at the floor. The median length-weighted mean dendritic diameter is ~0.49 vs 0.58 µm in mouse and ~0.59 vs 0.68 µm in human (unfloored vs floored).
- Within a cell type, the electrophysiology doesn’t change. For example, Pvalb interneurons reconstructed early (n = 37) vs late (n = 17) have the same τ/Rin capacitance and the same traced dendritic length, but traced diameters differ by a factor of ~1.5, and so does reconstructed membrane area.
- Human cells were almost all reconstructed in the later period, so the change is partly confounded with species.
This matters for anything normalized by membrane area: fitted specific capacitance and axial resistivity, conductance densities, surface-area features.
Questions
- Was there a change in the tracing or radius-estimation procedure (tool version, automatic radius estimation, default minimum radius, imaging or processing) around these specimen IDs?
- Is the procedure used for each reconstruction recorded anywhere (metadata, SWC header, API field) so users can group cells by protocol?
- Is there a recommended way to harmonize diameters across periods, or a view on which convention is closer to the true dendritic diameter?
I’m happy to share the analysis code and the per-cell list of conv
entions and specimen IDs if that would help.
Thank you,
Tanguy Damart
